Social Media Isn’t Enough—Here’s Why You Need an Email List

What Would You Do If Instagram Disappeared Tomorrow?

Let’s say you wake up tomorrow, and Instagram (or your favorite social platform) is gone.

No warning. No explanation. No way to recover your followers.

How would you reach your audience?

For many business owners, the answer is they wouldn’t. They’ve built their entire marketing strategy around social media.

Here’s the problem: You don’t own your social media audience.

• Instagram owns your followers.
• Facebook controls your reach.
• Algorithms decide whether your audience even sees your content.

But there’s one marketing asset that you do own—your email list.

If you want real control over your business growth, you need to stop relying solely on social media and start building an email list.

Why Your Business Needs an Email List

The problem is that most business owners think social media is enough—but it’s not a reliable long-term strategy.

The Solution is an email list that gives you a direct connection to your audience—without algorithms getting in the way.

• You own your email list (no one can take it away from you)
• Email gets higher engagement than social media (20-30% open rates vs. 5% organic reach)
• Email builds deeper relationships (subscribers are more invested than casual followers)
• Email converts better (subscribers are more likely to buy than social media followers)

Key Takeaway: Social media is great for discovery—but email is where real relationships (and sales) happen.

How to Build an Email List That Works

Step 1: Create a High-Value Lead Magnet

People won’t join your email list just because you ask. They need a reason. Offer them a valuable freebie (lead magnet) in exchange for their email.

Examples of high-performing lead magnets:

• Guides & checklists – “The Small Business Email Strategy Guide”
• Templates – “5 Email Swipe Files for Your First Funnel”
• Mini-courses – “Email Marketing 101: 3-Day Free Training”

Takeaway: The more valuable your freebie, the more people will sign up.

Step 2: Promote Your Lead Magnet Everywhere

Even if you create an amazing freebie, no one will sign up if they don’t know about it.

• Add opt-in forms to your website, blog, and social media profiles
• Mention your freebie in your Instagram Stories, posts, and Reels
• Include an email signup link in your email signature
• Run a low-cost ad campaign to drive signups

Takeaway: Building an email list isn’t something you do “once in a while”. Promote your freebie consistently!

Step 3: Nurture Your Subscribers with Valuable Emails

Many business owners get people on their list—but then don’t know what to send.

• Welcome Sequence – Introduce yourself & set expectations
• Weekly Value Emails – Share tips, insights, or behind-the-scenes content
• Engagement Emails – Ask questions, run polls, and get replies
• Sales Emails – Offer services, promotions, or launches

Takeaway: Don’t just collect emails—build a relationship with your list!

Final Thoughts: Your Email List is Your Most Valuable Marketing Asset

If social media disappeared tomorrow, would your business survive?

• Social media is great for visibility—but your email list is where real business happens.
• An email list gives you control over your audience and marketing.
• The sooner you start building your list, the stronger your business foundation will be.

Want to get going, but not sure where to start? Book a Free Discovery Call and we can chat about how I can help.

You might also like…

• Is Social Media your Only Marketing Tool?
• No More Guilt: Practical Advice for Balance Business & Family
• Save Time on Social Media with the Magic of Metricool’s Autolist Feature

If you’re interested in learning more about how 17hats can help you in your business, you can start with a 7 day free trial, which you will find at www.17hats.com. Just click on Start Your 7-Day Trial. Once the trial is over, or you’re ready to purchase, you’ll want to use my referral code, debmitzel, at checkout to get 50% off your first year of membership. 😊

Or, if you are ready to purchase right away without doing the trial, you can use my referral link to sign up and get the discount: https://referrals.17hats.com/card/debmitzel

Deb Mitzel is Your 17hats Guide—an experienced Small Business Operations Consultant and Coach, as well as a 17hats Implementation Specialist. With a passion for empowering small business owners, Deb specializes in helping clients reclaim their time so they can focus on building businesses that support their personal and professional dreams. Deb believes in creating an Integrated Life—a harmony where your business and personal life work together to serve you best. She knows that with the right systems, strategies, and a little guidance, you can build a business that is a blessing, not a burden. If you’re ready to simplify your processes and maximize your impact with 17hats or other tailored strategies, Deb offers a Free Discovery Call to explore how she can help. Click below to schedule your call and take the first step toward turning your vision into reality.

Schedule Discovery Call

Disclaimer: Some of the links are affiliate links, which means that if you choose to make a purchase, I will earn a commission. This commission comes at no additional cost to you. Please understand that I have experience with all of these companies, and I recommend them because they are helpful and useful, not because of the small commissions I make if you decide to buy something.  Please do not spend any money on these products unless you feel you need them or that they will help you achieve your goals.